Jesse James and Kostas Anagnopoulos moved to Rensselaerville in 2016, in part because of the Palmer House Café, where they’d become regulars.
They bought a building just three doors down. But then, almost as soon as they moved in, the Palmer House closed. “We were out of luck,” James recalls.
After nervously watching prospective buyers tour the property for years, they decided to take it on themselves. The result is Hamlet, a restaurant that builds on the building’s history while establishing an identity of its own.
A Building With a Past
Known as Union Hall, the building dates to 1801 and has served as a residence, inn, and shop. One local resident, whose grandparents ran the Rice General store there, gave James and Anagnopoulos a collection of “Rice dollars,” the store’s former currency, now framed in Hamlet’s vestibule.
Restoring the space took three years of work, including lifting the building to install a new foundation. The couple brought considerable design chops to the restoration effort. Together, they founded Aesthetic Movement, a design and wholesale agency, the Shoppe Object gift show, the homewares brand Sir/Madam, and Pidgin, an antiques and home goods shop in nearby Oak Hill. Their work also extends to Messrs. House, another historic Rensselaerville property they’re restoring as a guest house and event space.


With help from longtime collaborator Lisa Ano, the finished look mixes vintage fixtures with new millwork, including a bar made from century-old chestnut. “We were very committed to creating a space that one wouldn’t identify by a particular decade,” James explains.
I love how the light changes within the rooms and how they feel as the sun goes down and the candles take over.
Jesse James
It’s convincing enough that newly constructed details blend with the originals. Among my favorites is the theater kitchen, a glass-fronted workspace where fresh bread from Leavened is displayed for diners to admire and cut for service with cultured butter and big flaky salt. The space echoes the Palmer House’s former open kitchen, while the bulk of the cooking happens in a larger kitchen tucked away at the back of the building.
In the dining room, glossy painted walls, vintage lighting, richly upholstered seating, and flickering candles create a space that is elegant without being formal, where diners can celebrate an occasion or simply stop in for dinner.

“You might have someone who’s celebrating an anniversary and is dressed to the nines sitting next to someone who just got out of the garden and still has mud on their boots, and they strike up a conversation,” James says. “That makes it all worth it.”
That mix was evident during my visit. Older couples enjoyed quiet dinners, friends caught up over drinks, and a casually dressed man settled in at the bar. Everyone seemed equally at home.
Food Worth the Trip
Executive chef Matthew Hamilton brings experience at Prune, Zuni Café, and with Chez Panisse, along with his own New York restaurants, Uovo and Lulu & Po, to Hamlet. He was the one to approach James and Anagnopoulos after hearing about the project through mutual friends.
Anagnopoulos, whose family is Greek, brought memories of summers spent in Greece. The three spent a year developing a menu influenced by Mediterranean cooking and the region’s agriculture.
“It felt really important to us that the food wasn’t performative in any way,” James says.


That doesn’t mean Hamilton is playing it safe. October’s menu ranges from chicken liver and pancetta pâté with house pickles to Heather Ridge lamb meatballs with heirloom tomato coulis and Greek feta. Pasta kerchief combines local mushrooms, butternut squash, and sage, while a dinner omelette gets dressed up with crème fraîche, chives, and bottarga. There’s even tzimmes, the traditional Jewish dish of carrots and dried fruit, here made with dates, orange, and cinnamon.
It’s an appealingly eclectic menu that makes narrowing down an order surprisingly difficult.
We started with housemade pickles and that beautiful fresh bread from the theater kitchen, followed by an apple and fennel salad with celery, walnuts, tarragon, and crème fraîche. The salad was crisp and bright, exactly what we wanted before getting into the richer stuff.
The vegetables deserve particular attention. Roasted baby beets were tender and chilled, while fried Brussels sprouts with sweet chili sauce and peanut picada had a perfect kick of heat. Combining the sprouts with pickled carrot was one of the best decisions of the evening.


A whole rainbow trout arrived—head and all—with impossibly crisp skin, shaved fennel, red onion, and fresh chermoula. The pan-roasted chicken, meanwhile, was almost suspiciously good—tender and beautifully cooked, with a silky jus that had sent all my normal restaurant chicken skepticism out the window. The accompanying roasted cabbage was delicate and tender, though I’d have happily taken a little more char.
And then there was the fondant potato.
I’ve thought about this potato an unreasonable number of times since dinner. The accompanying Dijon beurre monté was the real revelation: rich, smooth, tangy, and good enough to make me consider asking for a spoon. If Hamlet ever sells it by the jar, I’ll be first in line.
Hamilton balances richness with acidity, using pickles, herbs, and carefully made sauces to keep the food from feeling heavy. Nothing looks like it requires tweezers to assemble, but there’s plenty of skill behind every plate.
The menu names local suppliers, including Heather Ridge Farm, Kuhar Family Farm, Barbers Farm, and Potter Hollow Garden.
The Pleasure of Staying Awhile
Hamlet’s cocktail list favors classics, while the wines by the glass offer some interesting discoveries. I started with a skin-contact Carricante blend from Mount Etna in Sicily, bright and citrusy with a little texture, before moving to a Žilavka from Herzegovina, a dry white known for its floral notes and crisp acidity. It’s a welcome departure from the usual Chardonnay and Sauvignon Blanc. The cider list is especially noteworthy, featuring six offerings from Heartsby True, a producer based right in Rensselaerville.

Non-drinkers have plenty of options, too. The Hamlet Hollow Spritz is made with Pentire Coastal, fresh herbs, lime, and lavender, followed by a pleasantly sweet housemade lavender-ginger soda.
For dessert, the Stewart’s Sundae is a nod to the beloved upstate convenience store chain, with vanilla ice cream, lavender caramel, crunchy peanuts, coconut, and lightly sweetened whipped cream. The Syllabub, an old-fashioned dessert of whipped cream, sugar, and alcohol. As someone who has never needed encouragement to eat whipped cream by the spoonful, I was immediately sold.
But the dessert’s history is even better. Per James, early versions involved milking a cow directly into wine or cider, allowing the warm milk to froth as it hit the alcohol. Thankfully, Hamlet’s version requires no trip to the barn.


In the bathroom, cloth hand towels replace disposable paper towels. Coffee arrives in a French press. (I enjoyed mine with Amaro Nonino.) It’s the casual elegance in these details that set the new Rensselaerville restaurant apart.
“We didn’t hold back in our effort to create a space that will be there for the next 100 years,” he says. “We’re creating beautiful food, we’re creating a warm environment, and we’re creating it for everybody.”
Hamlet
1462 County Route 351, Rensselaerville, NY 12147
https://www.hamletny.com | @@hamletny





