Silvia Owners Open New Woodstock Restaurant The Penny

With the cafe for coffee, sandwiches, and ready-to go eats and the tavern for sit-down dinner and drinks, the Penny aims to be an affordable, everyday eatery for locals and visitors

“The whole property will basically take care of everyone’s needs all day long—from coffee, fresh-baked pastries, breakfast sandwiches turning into lunch sandwiches, salads, and moving into bar service and full sit-down dinner,” says Craig Leonard, one of the co-owners of new Woodstock restaurant The Penny. “It’s an ambitious project, so hopefully people will be patient with us.”

The Penny takes over the lush property at 43-45 Mill Hill Road at the heart of Woodstock, most recently occupied by Gemela, itself the successor to the Mud Club and Early Terrible. While Leonard himself was a partner in Gemela, in its new incarnation as The Penny, he is joined by his family: Betty Choi, Doris Choi, and Niall Grant, the quartet behind Woodstock restaurants Silvia and Good Night. “Basically Doris is the focus,” Leonard says of the draw. “She is the genius behind Silvia and Good Night and she’s going to bring that magic to this new venture.”

With bluestone terraces, cherry trees, lawns, and beautiful landscaping, the property has the feeling of being Woodstock’s backyard. The two wooden buildings have operated as single and separate businesses over the years. Under the Silvia team, both spots will go by the name The Penny, with the smaller building housing the cafe and the larger building home to the tavern.

The Penny Cafe 

The Penny cafe opened on April 23, and the tavern followed on May 20. “The cafe is its own entity right now,” Doris Choi says. “I finally figured out what it is I want out of it. I want really great egg sandwiches on really great buns that we make in-house; really great salads; really good lemonades; really good pastries.” And of course, really good coffee—something both Choi and Leonard underscored. They are sourcing from Kingston-based, small-batch roaster Area Coffee Co. In addition to espresso drinks and made-to-order items, the cafe also offers quick grab-and-go options for breakfast and lunch. 

The menu starts in the morning with breakfast sandwiches, alongside pastries and baked goods that feel a little more thoughtful than standard café fare. From there, it shifts into a lunch lineup of sandwiches, salads, and grab-and-go items, with an emphasis on fresh, bright, easy eating rather than anything overly heavy. Taken together, the menu suggests a casual but well-considered daytime operation: good coffee, sturdy sandwiches, crisp salads, and house-made details that keep it feeling polished without losing its everyday appeal.

Breakfast at The Penny Cafe leans hearty and a little playful, with a pastry case that includes croissants, chocolate croissants, blueberry turnovers, almond bear claws, kouign-amann, and spinach quiche. The bigger draw, though, is the lineup of breakfast egg sandwiches: the Deli with cheddar, tomato jam, and your choice of bacon, ham, or avocado; Beans & Avocado with sofrito and chili cheddar; Chorizo Sausage with beans, sofrito, and chili cheddar; Smash Beef & Onion with provolone and pickle aioli; and Mortadella with provolone and horseradish mustard. It reads as a breakfast menu with real appetite behind it, and Choi’s signature twist of flavors for a result that is comforting, savory, and more distinctive than the usual café offerings.

Iced coffees and breakfast sandwiches from The Penny cafe
Iced coffees and breakfast sandwiches from The Penny cafe

The lunch sandwich menu also packs a punch with options like the vegetarian ’Shroom Reuben with kraut, cheddar, and sourdough and the Green Falafel with chopped salad, tahini, harissa, and pita. Internationally inspired options include the Viet Chicken with carrot, cucumber, chili jam aioli, and baguette; and a Korean Philly with BBQ beef, kimchi, provolone, and a hoagie roll. Grab-and-go salads are popular with options including the famous Silvia Kale salad, shredded Greek, and a gem Caesar, plus proteins like Green Falafel, Crab & Shrimp Cake, roast chicken breast, and steelhead trout.

The Penny Tavern

Leonard is the design savant behind the elegant interiors at Silvia and Good Night, though he had an admittedly lighter touch in The Penny tavern. “There is very little you can do to that space asthetically—it’s already built out in wood,” he says. “We wanted to keep that barn feeling to the space, because it is cozy and comfortable.”
That said, they did add a large bar, which Choi feels was missing from Gemela’s interior. “You need a bar—it’s the focal point,” she says. “It pulls the space together, and it’s really nice and rustic. You want to create an intimate space so people can go out two to three times a week and not break the bank.”

The Penny Tavern. Photo by Goose Studio

The tavern’s interior has a small footprint, which will mean the Penny’s seating capacity varies greatly with the seasons. The interior can seat 35 to 40, while the covered patio and garden will take the overall capacity closer to 100 in the summer months. While Gemela was self-service, The Penny tavern will be a full service, sit-down restaurant.

Food Offerings

“Because I bought a smoker, everyone thought it was going to be Korean barbecue,” Choi says with a laugh. “I’m trying to incorporate the outdoors with some BBQ and some smoking, but it’s not the true essence of the menu.” So what is the essence? A New American-style tavern with globetrotting influences. 

“Turkish kebabs. Creole oysters. Peri peri chicken,” Choi says. “I want things to have a lot of flavor.” There will be a lunch and dinner menu with plenty of apps to share or eat on your own. The main goal with The Penny is affordability, the idea being to create a space that local residents can frequent. “I don’t want a tourist trap,” Choi says. “I really want it to be a place all year round for locals to come, sit, and have a local bar scene.”

Photo by Goose Studio.

In order to hit that delicious-but-affordable price point, Choi had to do a bit of mental gymnastics in designing the menu, settling on what she calls a high brow-low brow approach that is less precious than her other restaurants. “You can’t do surf and turf,” she says. “So you do one good ingredient, then build the menu around it with other more affordable things. If you’re doing a really nice beef or chicken or fish, you pair it with broccoli.”

The peri peri chicken thighs, for example, are marinated for 10 hours, smoked, then grilled—a high quality meat with a time-intensive prep that is then served with sauteed cabbage ($28). “Cabbage is a lowly vegetable, but it’s a workhouse—it’s plentiful and cheap,” Choi says. Another spring dish, “mac ‘n’ peas” takes advantage of the short English pea season for an offering made with “a dusting of parmesan and pecorino, lots of lemon, very good olive oil, and a little mint to bring out peas” ($16).

The tavern’s opening menu boasts a lineup that feels laid-back, generous, and built for repeat visits, with plenty of room for both snacky grazing and full dinner mode. There are broiled Creole oysters with pecorino and saltines, country pâté with pickled vegetables and mustard, and smoked baked brie glossy with fig, pecan, and hot honey. That globetrotting streak shows up with dishes like chorizo and patatas with a harissa-chipotle aioli; garlic shrimp with tomato, broiled feta, olive, and pita; and ají amarillo mussels with corn, zucchini, and quinoa.

When asked about the role she sees her Woodstock restaurants playing in the local dining scene, Choi says: “They are three separate things. Silvia is really a rustic, wood-fired restaurant that pays homage to the primal—animals and vegetables. Good Night is more fancy, more celebratory—cocktails and big groups of people having parties. The Penny is more casual, more loose, more everyday.” She sees the latest venture as a way to give back to the local community by creating a space that is accessible and retains something of the character of the town. With most plates clustered between $14 and $28, the menu lands squarely in the sweet spot Choi described: flavorful and considered, but still casual enough to become part of the weekly rhythm.

“The whole footprint of this property is so wonky and weird and wild looking,” Choi says. “I like it. It’s not precious, not refined, but there’s a really beautiful landscape with cherry trees and lilacs and all the iron tables. It just feels like Woodstock. And the location is freaking awesome.”


The Penny
43-45 Mill Hill Road, Woodstock

The Penny cafe is open 8 AM-4 PM and the tavern is open from 11 AM to 9 or 10 PM.

Read Next